You may need to check print indexes for reviews of older books. Book Review Digest and Book Review Index are the best places to start your search for older reviews.
Book Review Digest (for reviews dating back to 1905) – 2nd Floor Reference Section Z1219 C95
The citation will consist of the name of the original source or journal and the date and issue information.
Note: Book Review Digest provides you with part of the review, but you should try to track down the full review in the original publication.
Book Review Index (for reviews dating back to 1965) – 2nd Floor Reference Section Z1035 A1 B6